It has been two years since Brendon McCullum, newly appointed as the coach of England’s Test team, expressed his desire for the role over a similar position with the white-ball team, citing that “the team is flying” and “I wasn’t interested in a cushy kind of gig.” With the recent dismissal of Matthew Mott leaving the white-ball position open again, it’s clear that motivations for taking the job have changed significantly.
The team is currently underperforming, aging, and due for a significant overhaul. The silver lining is that this moment is nearly optimal for such a transition: after three World Cups in under two years, there’s now a lull with only the Champions Trophy—an event of lesser importance—scheduled in Pakistan for early 2025, before a series of World Cups and the return of the sport to the Olympics between February 2026 and October 2028.
The encouraging news for the new coach is that England’s best team should be competitive against any global side; the downside is that he might never have the opportunity to select it.
In recent times, the structure of England’s cricket schedule has shifted from being packed to downright perplexing: including two days of training before every Test, one day for each white-ball match, plus recovery days after each game and additional time for international flights or domestic venue changes, the 123 days between their next game and the conclusion of their New Zealand tour in December lead to players being scheduled for 142 days.
The notion that McCullum could oversee the white-ball team without sacrificing his responsibilities with the Test squad, as suggested by former captain Eoin Morgan last week, falls apart quickly when faced with this congested schedule. “We can’t put our best team on the park,” Mott stated last year. “We’ve just got to find a way to compete.”
The role now being sought by the England and Wales Cricket Board’s managing director of men’s cricket, Rob Key, comes with a host of dilemmas and trade-offs. Additionally, it offers a lower salary than an IPL head coach position, which typically requires only about two months of commitment each year.
Therefore, it may be challenging to attract Kumar Sangakkara, the amiable Sri Lankan who governs Jos Buttler’s IPL team, the Rajasthan Royals. However, he resides in Dorset, enjoys a strong rapport with the captain, and is likely to be approached.
Other notable and conveniently located foreign candidates include Stephen Fleming, another seasoned and well-respected IPL head coach, currently with Southern Brave in the Hundred, and Mike Hussey, the New Zealander who coaches batting at Chennai Super Kings, and has collaborated with Buttler multiple times, including at the 2022 T20 World Cup, and is currently with Welsh Fire.
after newsletter promotion
In the meantime, Andrew Flintoff, in his first senior coaching role at Northern Superchargers, is seen as the bookmakers’ favorite. In March, Key referred to him as “a worthy candidate” that anyone in his position “would be foolish not to consider.” However, the 46-year-old would be a questionable choice for several reasons: while he brings charisma and players enjoy his presence, his limited coaching experience, close friendship with Key, and ties to ECB chairman Richard Thompson—who leads the agency representing him—should eliminate him from contention.
Should the search focus on an English coach, James Foster possesses stronger credentials: he is two years younger and notably more experienced, despite Flintoff landing his Hundred role as the team sought a fresh face after finishing last under Foster’s previous oversight.
Morgan was a natural leader during his previous successful renewal of the team, but has indicated that “the timing is not right” for his return, which seems accurate—he also lacks coaching experience and his close relationship with the players he led to victory in the 2019 World Cup may hinder necessary changes. Timing issues might also exclude Rahul Dravid, as it’s barely a month since he stepped down as the head coach of India. Conversely, this could be an ideal opportunity for Jonathan Trott, Afghanistan’s head coach, who has expressed interest in the position and whose star is currently on the rise.
Trott previously described his career aspirations as “hoping for a very, very good World Cup and then considering the options.” Since then, he and Afghanistan have enjoyed two remarkable World Cups, including a win over England. Trott’s contract concludes in December, but he has just signed on to lead Pretoria Capitals in January’s SA20, positioning him as a potential outsider in this selection process.
Marcus Trescothick, the interim coach, currently benefits from the advantage of being in the role. If Key struggles to attract the top names on his list, and should England secure positive outcomes against Australia next month, the temptation to simply let things continue may be strong.
Key’s responsibility, however, is to look past convenient fixes: if England has difficulty assembling their strongest team on the field, what they truly need is the best team off it.
